About the Disputationes

In the scholastic system of education of the Middle Ages, the Disputationes offered a formalised method of debate designed to uncover and establish truths in theology and in sciences. Fixed rules governed the process: they demanded dependence on traditional written authorities and the thorough understanding of each argument on each side. The famous Disputatio of Barcelona, called for in the summer of 1263 by King James I of Aragon, is the most important and well-known of the inter-faith Disputationes that took place between Christian and Jewish theologians in the late Middle Ages. In the Disputatio of Barcelona of 1263, the disputantes were Friar Paulus Christianus (Dominican, and a convert rabbi) and Rabbi Moses ben Nachman (also known as Nachmanides, or Benastruch De Porta), from the Girona’s community, the most important scholar of Judaism in his time. They discussed theological questions in front of the king and his court, in the presence of the most important men, both Christian and Jewish, of the already prosperous and influential city of Barcelona.

Inspired by this original Disputatio, the Academia Europaea-Barcelona Knowledge Hub (AE-BKH) began organising the modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona series of annual debates starting in 2013. Bringing invited disputantes, a woman and a man, followed by questions by the audience, which is comprised of members of the local academic community. The total duration of the session is between 90 and 120 minutes. together two renowned experts (disputantes) holding different viewpoints on a common topic of social relevance, the series, now in its nineth edition, has covered a wide variety of topics in the exact, natural and social sciences. The debates follow a similar format consisting of a brief exposition by each of the two.

Trini Sotos
Logo Disputatio

The modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona, 20132021

On November 27, 2013, the AE-BKH celebrated its inaugural modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona by commemorating the 750th anniversary of the original medieval Disputatio. The topic of debate was “Social and state-of-the-art Medicine”, featuring neuroscientist Mara Dierssen (Centre for Genomic Regulation, UPF; president of the Spanish Society for Neuroscience) and philosopher Thomas Pogge (Yale University; leader of the Health Impact Fund).

On November 27, 2014, after the success of the first modern-time Disputatio of Barcelona in 2013, the AE-BKH organised a second modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona, with the collaboration of then with the United Nations University Institute on Globalization, Culture and Mobility (UNU-GCM). The topic was “The Mediterranean, bridge of cultures”, and the debate was held at the Sant Pau Historic Site where the UNU-GCM is located. Two Members of Academia Europaea (MAE), Maria Paradiso (geographer, Professor of Geography and Planning at the University of Sannio, Italy), and Enric Banda (geophysicist, director of Science and Environment at the “la Caixa” Foundation, Barcelona), discussed on different aspects of Mediterranean history and culture, as well as current opportunities and challenges.

On December 9, 2015, the third modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona was held in the Royal Chapel of Saint Agatha, in the Gothic Quarter. Two scholars, Núria Sebastian (vice-president of the European Research Council), and Ulises Cortés (from the Barcelona Supercomputing Centre), debated on “Natural vs Artificial Intelligence”. The session ended with an intense debate with the audience, who actively participated by posing several important questions to the speakers.

On November 21, 2016, the fourth modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona, was held at the Palau de la Generalitat and was presided by the President of the Government of Catalonia, Carles Puigdemont. It was devoted to the topic “Natural Life vs. Synthetic Life”. Two scholars, Anna Veiga (Centre for Regenerative Medicine, Barcelona) and Ricard Solé (Complex Systems Lab, PRBB, Barcelona), debated on the new challenges that current scientific advancements present to humanity. The disputantes shared their impressive knowledge on the topic with the audience, which was highly interested in the topic debated in the session.

On November 23, 2017, the fifth modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona was held at the Institute for Catalan Studies (IEC) in the Prat de la Riba Hall, the most solemn room in the IEC. The Disputatio focused on “Supercomputers: An instrument for science, technology and the progress of society.” The two disputantes were Mateo Valero, director of the Super Computing Center of Barcelona (BSC), who presented the modern supercomputers in terms of scientific and technological advancement, while Alison Kennedy, director of the STFC Hartree Centre (Daresbury, Warrington, UK), presented their role in the progress of society.

On November 28, 2018, the sixth modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona, entitled “Competition vs. Cooperation: Two economists’ points of view”, was held at the Institute for Catalan Studies (IEC) in Prat de la Riba Hall. The session was moderated by Salvador Barberà, Professor Emeritus of Economics at the Autonomous University of Barcelona and featured as disputantes Hervé Moulin (Donald J. Robertson Chair in Economics at the University of Glasgow), and Gabrielle Demange, (Director of Studies at the School of Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences, EHESS, in Paris). All three are Members of Academia Europaea, in the Economics, Business & Management Sciences Section.

On November 13, 2019, addressing the question “A new humanism for the 21st century? Specialisation vs. Generalisation. A debate on the future of knowledge”, the seventh modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona was held at the IEC. The disputantes were Silvia De Bianchi, Ramón y Cajal Fellow at the Department of Philosophy and Centre for the History of Science, Autonomous University of Barcelona (UAB), and Maciej Lewenstein, MAE, ICREA Research Professor and Quantum Optics Theory Group Leader at the Institute of Photonic Sciences (ICFO). Serving as moderator and coordinator was Alexander Fidora, MAE, ICREA Research Professor, Department of Ancient and Medieval Studies, UAB. The participants discussed key concepts including specialisation, generalisation, interdisciplinarity, humanities, science, development and realisation of the individual, offering their analyses of the present situation of knowledge as well as their visions for the future.

In 2020, in light of the COVID-19 pandemic and its widespread social impact, the AE-BKH decided to devote the eighth modern-day Disputatio of Barcelona to “Cities, Climate and Pandemics: Reflections from Urban Studies and Environmental Economics”. The session focussed on the essential role of cities in climate change mitigation and in the control of pandemics such as COVID-19. Barcelona, along with other major metropolises in the world, will provide for an interesting analysis. Coordinated and moderated by Alexander Fidora, MAE, ICREA Research Professor in the Department of Ancient and Medieval Studies, UAB, this debate attempted to shed new light on bringing together experts from different fields. The two disputantes were urbanist Kathrin Golda-Pongratz, MAE, UPC, and UIC Barcelona School of Architecture; and environmental economist Jeroen van den Bergh, ICREA Research Professor, ICTA-UAB. The session took place at the IEC, and followed a hybrid model of (limited) in-person attendance as well as access via live streaming on Zoom. (Details regarding registration intention was made available on the AE-BKH website.)

On December 1, 2021, the Disputatio of Barcelona was entitled Mental health and pandemics: burden and resilience, and addressed the aforementioned issues with the goal of providing an invaluable dialogue among expert scientists on the relationship between mental health and pandemics. The session tried to find consensus on priorities and possible paths forward as stakeholders establish action plans for the mid- and long-term. Serving as the two disputantes for the debate were Arcadi Navarro, MAE, ICREA Research Professor at Pompeu Fabra University and Director of the Pasquall Maragall Foundation and Eider Arenaza-Urquijo, Research Team Leader at the Barcelonaβeta Brain Research Center, Barcelona. The session took place at the IEC, and followed a hybrid model of (limited) in-person attendance as well as access via live streaming on Zoom.


We can consider that the modern-day Disputationes are a distinctive feature of the Academia Europaea-Barcelona Knowledge Hub, and must be continued in future years.


 DISPUTATIO OF BARCELONA, 2013 – 2022

 


 

YEAR

  DAY

       SITE

            TITLE

      CONVENOR

DISPUTANTE 1

DISPUTANTE 2

CO-ORGANISER

           URL


 

2013

27 Nov. Saló de Cent, City Council Building Social and state-of-the-art medicine: defining the way forward —- Thomas Pogge                        (Yale University) Mara Dierssen (CGR-UPF) Barcelona City Council http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2013/

 

2014

27 Nov. Saint Pau Historic Site The Mediterranean, bridge of cultures —- Maria Paradiso                (University of Sannio) Enric Banda                           (la Caixa Foundation) UNU-GCM http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2014/

 

2015

09 Dec. Royal Chapel of Saint Agatha Natural vs. Artificial intelligence —- Núria Sebastian                          (UPF) Ulises Cortés                        (BSC) http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2015/

 

2016

21 Nov. Palau de la Generalitat Natural life vs. Synthetic life —-

Anna Veiga                        (CMR[B])

Ricard Solé                          (UPF, PRBB)

http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2016/


 

2017

23 Nov. Institu d’Estudis Catalans (IEC) Supercomputers: instruments for science and technology and the progress of society

Enric Banda (BSC),          Fabrizio Gagliardi (BSC)

Mateo Valero                          (BSC) Alison Kennedy                    (STFC Hartree Centre) http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2017/

 

2018

28 Nov. Institut d’Estudis Catalans (IEC)

Competition vs. Cooperation: Two economists’ points of view

Salvador Barberà (UAB)

Hervé Moulin                              (University of Glasgow)

Gabrielle Demange                  (EHESS-Paris)

http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2018/


 

2019

13 Nov.

Institut d’Estudis Catalans (IEC) A new Humanism for the 21st century? Specialisation vs. generalisation Alexander Fidora (ICREA-UAB) Silvia de Bianchi                      (UAB) Matiej Lewenstein                  (ICREA-ICFO) http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2019-2/

 

2020

19 Jan. 2021

Virtual Cities, climate and pandemics: Reflections from urban studies and environmental economics Alexander Fidora (ICREA-UAB) Kathrin Golda-Pongratz            (UPC) Jeroen van den Bergh            (ICREA-ICTA) http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2020/

 

2021

01 Dec.

IEC & Streaming Mental health and pandemics: burden and resilience —- Arcadi Navarro                     (UPF) Eider Arenaza-Urquijo (Barcelonaβeta Brain Research Center) Pla Barcelona Ciència (Ajuntament de Barcelona) http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2021/

 

2022

15 Nov.

IEC & Streaming The urban between history, ecology and the digital – Challenges for the future of Barcelona Xavier Costa-Guix (Northeastern Univ., Boston) Kathrin Golda-Pongratz                (UPC) Georg Vrachliotis                     (TU Delft) Ajuntament de Barcelona http://barcelona.acadeuro.org/disputatio-of-barcelona/disputatio-of-barcelona-2022/

 

skyline